MODALITY IS A PROBLEM IN MODERN LINGUISTICS

Основное содержимое статьи

Mukaddas Rakhmiddinova

Аннотация

The study of modality in linguistics, encompassing pragmatic, semantic, and syntactic processes, has grown in popularity with the emergence of Cognitive Linguistics and constructionist grammars. While the interest in modality dates back to classical philosophers like Aristotle and Socrates, it continues to be a relevant topic in contemporary linguistic research. Modality refers to the denotation of mood, manner, or mode, and linguistic analysis focuses on the means of expressing these qualities and the associated encoding process.


This study explores core and semi-modals, which exhibit a range of modal nuances from personal feelings to assessments based on the speaker's knowledge. The article employs the "root" and "epistemic" distinctions preferred by Palmer to analyze modality in both linguistic and logical contexts. Root modality comprises root possibility and necessity, often associated with "deontic" (moral obligation) or "dynamic" (ability/opportunity) senses. Modality's usefulness lies in linguistic hedging, as deontic modals can vary from weak suggestions to strict commands depending on context.


Dynamic modality subtly hedges beliefs, similar to how moral conviction is hedged in deontic modality. For instance, sentences like "Hudson drives" (a) and "Hudson can drive" (b) display distinct semantic meanings. While (a) asserts Hudson's regular driving, (b) indicates his ability but not necessarily its application. This differentiation affects the speaker's commitment to the statement.


The study classifies modality into agent-oriented and speaker-oriented, depending on whether the agent performing the action is influenced or enables the condition, respectively. Additionally, the article discusses the role of force dynamics and argument structure in the representation of modality. Various linguistic treatments of English modals utilize epistemic and deontic categories, supplemented with additional types to capture the full range of meanings.


However, the complexity of modal data poses challenges for comprehensive analyses. Some researchers propose that modals represent a metaphorical mapping between the external world of socio-physical experience and the internal world of reasoning. Still, the proliferation of candidate meanings highlights the need for pragmatic interpretation. The article raises questions about the unitary semantic approach to modals and their historical development.


In conclusion, the ambiguity-based approach to modality, emphasizing a rigid distinction between epistemic and nonepistemic meanings, faces challenges with intermediate cases. An alternative perspective suggests that traditional modal categories may emerge as byproducts of the comprehension process rather than stable and fundamental semantic information guiding pragmatic interpretation.

Информация о статье

Как цитировать
Rakhmiddinova, M. (2023). MODALITY IS A PROBLEM IN MODERN LINGUISTICS. Interpretation and Researches, 1(12). извлечено от https://interpretationandresearches.uz/index.php/iar/article/view/1306
Раздел
Статьи

Библиографические ссылки

Balas E. Innovative research in life sciences: Pathways to scientific impact, public health improvement, and economic progress. John. 2018.

Danilevskaya N. Scientific text as the dynamics of evaluation actions. Bulletin of Perm University. Russian and Foreign Philology. 2009;20-28(In Russia).

Golyshkina L. Polyaspectivity of the compositional structure of a rhetorical text. Scientific Dialogue. 2019;94-109(In Russia):10.

Golyshkina LA. Decoding rhetoric: Theoretical and methodological substantiation of the scientific direction. Scientific Dialogue. 2020;5:9-24.

Klemenova EN, Kudryashov IA. Headings-judgments in English-language mass media texts: Epistemic modality, deontic modality, evidentiality. Bulletin of Novosibirsk State University Series: History Philology. 2018;17(6):97-107.

Kosyakova YS. News of the Southern Federal University. 2018;4:82-91.

Layonz D. Linguistic Semantics Introduction Yazyki Slavyanskoy Kultury. 2003.

Paducheva E. Sementic Researches Semantic of Time and Species in Russian Language Narrative Semantics Yazyki Slavyanskoy Kultury. 2010.

Paducheva E. Egocentric Units of Language Yazyki Slavyanskoy Kultury. 2019.

Palmer FR. Modality and the English Modals. 1990.

Papafragou A. Epistemic modality and truth conditions. Lingua. 2006;116(10):1688-702.

Poole R, Gnann A, Hahn-Powell G. Epistemic stance and the construction of knowledge in science writing: A diachronic corpus study. Journal of English for Academic Purposes. 2019;42.

Rizomilioti V. Exploring epistemic modality in academic discourse using corpora. Educational Linguistics2006. p. 53-71.

Sakharova A. Linguistic means of expressing objective epistemic modality in scientific discourse. Scientific Dialogue. 2020;4:151-63.

Salieva L. Rhetorical competence as the basic goal of education in the era of information dictatorship. Bulletin of the Higher School. 2017;93-96(In Russia):8.

Сhernyavskaya VE. Scientific result in research paper in linguistics. Speech Genres. 2016;1(13):56-64.